By Mark Ryan, BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist
There's an assumption that all gay men want, or should want, a non monogamous relationship. It isn't true, and I see the damage that assumption does from both directions. Some of the gay couples I work with feel judged for wanting monogamy, as though it makes them less authentically part of their own community. Others feel the opposite pressure, pushed towards an assumption that non monogamy is simply how gay relationships work, without ever being asked what they want. Neither pressure belongs in a healthy relationship, and neither is something I bring into the room.
What is true is that non monogamy is common among gay male couples. In a study of 566 gay male couples in the San Francisco Bay Area, nearly equal numbers reported monogamous and open agreements (Hoff et al., 2010). It was a US community sample, so the exact balance will differ elsewhere, but it shows that if this is your situation you are not unusual. That can lift some of the shame that attaches itself to the conversation. Being common is not the same as being right for you, though. This article is for couples who are already navigating non monogamy and want it to work better, and it makes no argument that it's what you should be doing.
There's a cultural history behind this too. Gay male relationships largely developed outside the institutions that shaped heterosexual coupledom for centuries, marriage, religious sanction and inherited family scripts, and for decades they had no legal recognition at all. In my experience, many couples build their norms from scratch as a result, often within chosen family communities that have already learned to define commitment on their own terms. Non monogamy, for many couples, grows out of that freedom and not out of any difficulty with intimacy or commitment. None of this makes it compulsory or monogamy a lesser choice. It only explains why the conversation looks different here than it does for most heterosexual couples arriving at the same decision.
When monogamy is the minority position in the room
Some of the gay men I see want monogamy clearly and simply and still arrive feeling they have to justify that choice, sometimes to friends, sometimes to a previous partner, sometimes only to themselves. When the culture around you treats non monogamy as the more sophisticated, more authentically queer option, wanting exclusivity can start to feel like a failure of imagination and not a legitimate preference. I've had clients describe feeling boring, unadventurous, even a little ashamed, for wanting the same thing a monogamous heterosexual couple might want without a second thought.
This matters clinically because shame makes honest negotiation almost impossible. A partner who feels embarrassed about wanting monogamy will often go along with an open arrangement they don't want, hoping the feeling will pass or that they'll adjust to it. It rarely works that way. Wanting monogamy is not a smaller or more limited way of loving someone, and a couple's agreement only holds if both partners are saying what they want and not what they think they're supposed to want, in either direction.
Neither structure is the better one. In the same study of 566 couples, there was no difference in relationship satisfaction between couples with monogamous agreements and couples with open ones (Hoff et al., 2010). What seems to matter far more is whether the agreement is honest, clear and shared.
Monogamy itself is a choice, not the default that non monogamy deviates from. Plenty of monogamous relationships were never actively discussed as such and were simply assumed. Monogamy that hasn't been actively chosen isn't automatically fragile, but it isn't automatically solid either, and it deserves the same honest conversation any other structure would need. I've written about this at greater length in Modern Love, Many Forms.
How gay couples structure this
Agreements among gay male couples fall along a continuum and not into two clean boxes of open and closed. In interviews with 39 couples, a wide range of agreement types emerged. Among couples with open agreements, most set rules about when, where, how often and with whom outside sex was allowed. Most couples had matching agreements, but a small number turned out to have different ideas of what they had agreed. The researchers concluded that agreements helped couples by giving the relationship boundaries, supporting a non heteronormative identity and meeting the couple's sexual needs (Hoff and Beougher, 2010).
I think that last finding is worth taking to heart. An agreement is not a loophole or a sign that something is wrong. For many couples it is a way of looking after the relationship, and the effort of putting it into words is part of what makes it work.
Couples whose agreements don't match are a small minority in the research, but they are the ones I see most often in practice, because they are what tends to bring a couple through the door. Couples rarely arrive describing themselves as having a mismatched agreement. They arrive describing a specific incident that doesn't make sense to them, a boundary they thought was clear that turned out not to be, or a partner who did something one of them considers a clear breach and the other considers well within the rules. Almost always, when we slow down and compare what each partner believed the agreement was, the two versions don't match. Nobody was lying. The agreement was never as settled as it felt.
This is easier to miss than you might expect. In a national US sample of 361 male couples, only about half agreed with each other that they had an agreement at all, and in just over half of couples both men were keeping to it (Mitchell, 2014). The author concluded that couples need to be more explicit and detailed when making and communicating their agreements.
Where this tends to show up in the room
Most of the gay couples I see around non monogamy are not deciding whether to open up. They are already practising some form of it and have hit a specific, concrete problem. Something has happened that one partner reads as within the agreement and the other reads as a breach, or an agreement that worked well for a year has stopped fitting without either partner saying so out loud.
Broken agreements are not unusual, and they are rarely the villain story they first seem. In my experience an agreement that goes unspoken for long enough erodes gradually and does not break all at once. That is often harder to work with in therapy, because by the time a couple arrives, both partners may have been managing a private, unstated version of the relationship for months. Trust, good communication and a sense of being supported tend to protect an agreement, and they are also the first things that suffer when it frays.
The work in these sessions is rarely about deciding whether non monogamy is right for the couple. It's closer to detective work, going back to what was agreed, where the language was vague enough to allow two different interpretations, and what has changed since the agreement was made that nobody has revisited. Apps, travel, a new friendship that has started to blur into something else, a partner spending more on outside connections than the couple ever discussed, these are the ordinary triggers, and almost none of them are about whether non monogamy itself is working.
Monogamy is a choice, not the default that non-monogamy deviates from
What the agreement needs to cover, specifically
Vague agreements are the most common thing I help couples fix. "We're open, but nothing serious" or "just don't bring it home" sound like agreements, and they are not specific enough to survive contact with a real situation. The couples who do well tend to have talked through detail that can feel unromantic in the moment. Does outside sex happen together or apart? Does it need to be with the same person more than once? What gets disclosed and when? And what happens if the rules get broken, rather than assuming that possibility away?
A few specifics tend to matter most in practice.
Do dating apps stay active and visible, or get archived for the relationship's duration?
Can an outside partner be a repeat connection, or does it need to stay a one off?
How much time, money or emotional energy can an outside connection absorb before it needs discussing?
What is either partner comfortable with their friends or family knowing?
What does "disclosure" mean in practice, a full account afterwards, a same day mention, or simply an honest answer if asked directly?
Couples who have never named these specifics often discover they were each assuming a different answer, usually at the worst possible moment to find out. It can help to talk it through on a walk or over dinner and not in the middle of a row, and to write the agreement down in plain words so you both hold the same version.
Sexual health communication belongs in the agreement as well, not as clinical advice, which sits outside what I offer, but as a relational agreement like any other. That means what testing looks like, how and when status gets shared, and what happens if either partner's situation changes. It is interesting that HIV prevention did not rank as a primary motivation for making an agreement for any of the 39 couples interviewed (Hoff and Beougher, 2010), and in the larger study of 566 couples it came behind every motivation centred on the relationship itself (Hoff et al., 2010). Couples were more often motivated by wanting boundaries, honesty and a shared sense of what the relationship was. Reducing the agreement to a health precaution tends to miss what it's doing for the couple, which is protecting the relationship as much as protecting either partner's body.
Renegotiating without waiting for a crisis
The couples whose agreements hold up longest treat renegotiation as routine maintenance and not emergency repair. A brief, scheduled check in, monthly is common, doesn't need to be clinical or heavy. It can be as simple as each partner naming one thing that's working and one thing that feels slightly off before it becomes a bigger conversation. Agreements that are only ever revisited after something has gone wrong start to feel like a courtroom and not a relationship, and couples begin avoiding the conversation altogether, which is exactly how mismatched agreements form in the first place.
It also helps to treat a request to renegotiate as information and not betrayal. A partner who says "this part isn't working for me anymore" is not necessarily saying the relationship has failed. Usually they're telling you about a real change, in desire, in capacity, in what they need to feel secure. Couples who can hear that without treating it as an attack tend to adapt far more easily than couples who experience every renegotiation as a threat to the whole structure.
When the agreement itself has become the problem
Sometimes what looks like a non monogamy problem is an agreement that no longer reflects who either partner has become. People change. What felt exciting and freeing three years into a relationship can feel hollow or even threatening ten years in, and neither partner is wrong for having changed, even if it makes the conversation harder. I encourage couples to treat their agreement as something to be revisited on purpose, and not only after something has gone wrong. An agreement that's only ever discussed in crisis will always feel like a negotiation under fire and not a shared decision.
If one of you is unhappy with the arrangement, that deserves to be heard and not managed. A good agreement is one both people can live in comfortably, and it is always fine to say that it no longer fits and to look for something that does, whether that is a different kind of openness, a return to exclusivity, or a pause while you work out what you each want.
Jealousy still shows up here
An open or non monogamous agreement doesn't remove jealousy from a relationship, and some couples arrive believing that jealousy means the arrangement has failed. It usually means something much more ordinary is happening underneath, and it needs reading properly and not treating as a verdict on the relationship structure itself. I've written in more depth about jealousy in relationships generally and about the specific patterns jealousy takes in non monogamous relationships, including what compersion is and what it isn't. Both are useful reading if jealousy is the thing bringing you here.
If jealousy or insecurity is part of what you are living with, I have written a free reflection page, Jealousy and insecurity, and what they might be telling you. It is for you on your own, it is fillable and printable, and it is free to download.
Where therapy fits
I don't come into this work trying to move any couple towards monogamy or away from it. My job is to help you build an agreement that is honest, specific and properly shared, and not one that sounds settled but turns out to mean two different things to two different people. For some couples that means renegotiating the rules. For others it means recognising that the agreement was never the problem, and something older or unrelated is. If you're navigating any of this, I'd also point you towards a wider look at non monogamy and relationship structures, which covers the ground this article doesn't.
If you'd like to talk this through, I offer a free 30 minute consultation, in person in London or by video.
About the Author
Mark Ryan is a BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist working in person across central London, from rooms in Pimlico, Kensington, and Angel. He works with couples, individuals, and polycules on relationship issues including jealousy, affairs and betrayals, sex problems, and considered separation. His practice is integrative, sex-positive, and affirming of all relationship structures and identities.
References
Hoff, C. C., & Beougher, S. C. (2010). Sexual agreements among gay male couples. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 39(3), 774 to 787. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-008-9393-2
Hoff, C. C., Beougher, S. C., Chakravarty, D., Darbes, L. A., & Neilands, T. B. (2010). Relationship characteristics and motivations behind agreements among gay male couples: Differences by agreement type and couple serostatus. AIDS Care, 22(7), 827 to 835. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540120903443384
Mitchell, J. W. (2014). Characteristics and allowed behaviors of gay male couples' sexual agreements. The Journal of Sex Research, 51(3), 316 to 328. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2012.727915
