If You Don't Want Couples Therapy: An Honest Guide for the Sceptic

By Mark Ryan, BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist

You have a partner who wants couples therapy and you don't. You are reading this because some part of you is trying to work out whether your reluctance is the right instinct or whether you might be missing something. That is a reasonable thing to be working out.

This piece is written for you. It is not an attempt to talk you into anything. It is written by a London relationship therapist who, in my experience, sees one reluctant partner in a great many of the couples who walk through the door. That is my impression from my own practice and not a counted figure. The pattern is well known, and this piece is going to take it seriously rather than try to coax you out of it.

There is a companion piece to this one, written for the partner who wants therapy and is trying to work out what to do when their partner won't go: what to do when your partner won't go to couples therapy. You may want to read it after this one. They may have already read it. Both pieces are part of a deliberately even-handed pair.

In brief

  • Many of the standard objections to couples therapy are understandable, and I say which.

  • Some common fears are not borne out, in particular the fear that the therapist will take your partner's side.

  • Research suggests that in married couples seeking therapy, wives tend on average to reach each step towards therapy before husbands. If you are the slower partner, you are part of a documented pattern.

  • Couples therapy helps many couples, and how the work is done matters.

  • You can say no. If you do, there are better and worse ways of doing it.

What you are probably right about

Before anything else, it is worth saying that some of the standard objections to couples therapy are accurate. A reader who has been told that all reluctance is irrational is being managed, not informed. So here are the things you may be right about.

  • Bad couples therapy exists, and it can make things worse. Poorly trained therapists, therapists out of their depth, and therapists who do not understand couples work as distinct from individual work can all cause real damage. This is not a hypothetical risk. In a study of 249 people in consensually non monogamous relationships, how clients perceived their therapist's practice predicted how helpful they found therapy and whether they ended it early, and clients' perceptions of inappropriate practices were part of that (Schechinger et al., 2018). That was a study of one group of clients, but it fits what I would expect more widely.

  • Some therapists are not even handed. They (often subconsciously) side with the more articulate partner, the more distressed partner, or the partner who reminds them of themselves. This is a known problem in the field. In a meta-analysis of couple and family therapy, the authors point to the frequency of 'split' or 'unbalanced' alliances, where one partner feels much closer to the therapist than the other, and to the importance of ensuring safety (Friedlander et al., 2011).

  • Therapy can be used as a weapon by one partner against the other. Someone who books couples therapy to have a professional confirm that they are the reasonable one is not engaging in good faith. Recognising that this happens is pattern recognition, not paranoia. That is a clinical observation.

  • Pressure is a poor start. In my experience, being guilted or pressured into therapy by a partner makes it harder to engage, and the pressure itself is often the issue worth looking at separately.

  • Therapy takes time and costs money. For some couples, the honest outcome would have been to separate sooner, and a long course of therapy was not the right use of either resource. The authors of a randomised trial of couple therapy note that, despite the overall efficacy of psychotherapy, dropouts are substantial, many clients do not benefit, and therapists vary in effectiveness (Anker et al., 2009).

  • 'Talking about problems' does not automatically improve them. In some families of origin, talking made things worse, and the wariness inherited from that experience is not irrational.

None of these is a reason to dismiss the idea of couples therapy entirely. But naming them honestly is the price of being taken seriously. A reluctant partner who has these concerns is not unreasonable. They are paying attention to real risks.

What you may be wrong about

With that established, here are the things reluctant partners commonly believe that often turn out not to be true.

That the therapist will side with your partner

This is the single most common misunderstanding I encounter, and it is based on a misreading of what couples therapists do. The therapist is not there to adjudicate. They are there to be useful to both of you. A good couples therapist works hard against taking sides from the first session, because if they do not, the work does not function. The research is consistent with that. A study of 250 couples found that the alliance rated at the last session predicted outcomes for both partners, and that couples whose alliance started above average and grew were more likely to achieve reliable or clinically significant change (Anker et al., 2010). That sample was White, Euro Scandinavian and heterosexual, so I would be careful about how far it travels.

That you will be told you are the problem

In my experience, good couples therapy does not identify a problem partner. It identifies dynamics that both partners contribute to, often in ways neither has noticed. If a therapist starts telling one partner that they are the problem, the therapy is being done badly. The honest reality is closer to the opposite. Most couples therapy involves both partners discovering that they have a role in patterns they had previously attributed entirely to the other person.

That you will have to expose more than you are ready to

The pace of the slower partner is the pace of the therapy. A therapist who pushes faster than that is doing it wrong. You can say, at any point, that you are not ready to talk about something. A good therapist will respect that and find a way to work without forcing the issue. That is my view of good practice.

That therapy means agreeing your partner is right

It does not. You may leave therapy with a much clearer view of what you think is wrong with the relationship, and that view may be different from what your partner thinks. That is a legitimate outcome. Couples therapy can also be where you decide, with information rather than against information, that you and your partner want different things. In a study that followed 134 seriously and chronically distressed couples for five years after therapy, both therapies produced substantial improvements in marital satisfaction, and about a quarter of the couples (25.7 per cent and 27.9 per cent) were separated or divorced at follow up (Christensen et al., 2010). Good therapy makes that decision more honest, not less.

What the research says

Four findings from the research literature are worth knowing, because they address the questions a reluctant reader is likely to be holding.

Who tends to move first

Doss, Atkins and Christensen surveyed 147 married couples (294 individuals) who were in the process of seeking marital therapy. Using multilevel confirmatory factor analysis, they identified three relatively independent steps: problem recognition, treatment consideration and treatment seeking. On average, wives were rated as completing all three steps before their husbands. Gender role orientation, demographics, relationship satisfaction and specific relationship problems, especially husbands' dissatisfaction with sex, also predicted the steps towards therapy (Doss et al., 2003). That was a study of married husbands and wives who were seeking therapy, so it describes a pattern in one kind of couple. I cannot point to research on who moves faster in same sex couples, though in my experience in any couple one partner often moves toward therapy faster than the other. If you are the slower partner, you are part of a documented pattern. It is not a moral failing.

A longitudinal study of 213 couples over the first five years of marriage found that 36 per cent sought some form of outside help, and that individual and relationship difficulties predicted increased use of relationship books and marital therapy in the following year (Doss et al., 2009). That fits the general picture that couples tend to seek help after difficulties appear.

Whether it works

A review of a decade of research on couple therapy concluded that it positively affects about 70 per cent of the couples who receive it, that its effectiveness is comparable to that of individual therapies, and that it is far better than no treatment (Lebow et al., 2012). In a UK study from Tavistock Relationships' clinical setting, 877 people who completed at least two sessions of psychodynamic couple therapy showed a large fall in individual distress and a medium improvement in relationship satisfaction, with effect sizes similar to those in randomised trials (Hewison et al., 2016). Couples therapy is not less rigorous than individual work. If you would like to read more on what the evidence says, there is a longer piece on whether couples therapy is worth it.

What seems to matter once you are in the room

The most useful finding for a reluctant reader is about the working relationship. A meta analysis of 24 studies of alliance and outcome in couple and family therapy, of which seven were couple studies, found that the association between alliance and outcome was stronger in the couple studies (r = .37) than overall (r = .26) (Friedlander et al., 2011). The authors point to the importance of ensuring safety and of fostering a shared sense of purpose between partners. The evidence I can point to is therefore about how the work feels once it starts, not about how enthusiastic either of you was at the start. I have not found a study showing that willingness to engage is the strongest predictor of outcome. In my clinical experience, a reluctant partner who agrees to attend and takes part, even sceptically, can do good work, and I distinguish between reluctance, which is common and manageable, and disengagement, which is much harder to work with. That is my view and not a research finding. You do not have to want this for it to work. You must be willing to be in the room.

Tracking whether it is working

In a randomised trial of 410 people at a community family counselling clinic, couples whose therapists received regular feedback on their progress and on the quality of the alliance achieved nearly four times the rate of clinically significant change compared with treatment as usual (Anker et al., 2009). That gives a sceptic a concrete question to ask: how will we know whether this is working?

Couples therapy london

A reader who has been told that all reluctance is irrational is being managed, not informed.

The thing underneath the reluctance

Two observations worth sharing, because most articles on this topic avoid them. Both are from my clinical experience.

The first. A meaningful proportion of reluctant partners are reluctant because, somewhere underneath, they already suspect there is something they would need to face if they walked into a therapy room. A pattern of withdrawal. An avoidance of intimacy. An old wound from before the relationship. A way of showing up that they know has not been fair. The reluctance is sometimes less about the therapist or the room, and more about a quiet awareness that the room would surface something they have not been ready to look at. If withdrawal is part of it, I have written about stonewalling and emotional shutdowns and avoidant attachment.

If that is what is going on for you, it is worth knowing. Not because it means you should go to therapy, but because recognising it changes what the decision is. You are not deciding whether the therapist will be fair, or whether your partner is right about the relationship. You are deciding whether you are ready to begin work you suspect needs doing. That is a different question, and it deserves to be answered honestly.

The second observation is the counterweight. The keen partner, the one who has been pushing for therapy, almost always walks in hoping the work will be mostly about you. If you could just change a few things, then everything would be fine. This is so universal that I notice it in myself when I think about my own relationships. It is not a flaw in your partner; it is how minds work when they are tired and hurt.

But it has implications for what you should expect. Good couples therapy does not validate one partner's story about the other. Within the first two sessions, your partner will almost certainly be invited to look at their own role in the patterns they have been blaming on you. You may find that the therapy is not the set up you were expecting. In my experience it is a much more even-handed business than most reluctant partners walk in fearing. If blame has been part of how you talk, blame in relationships may help.

How to choose a therapist if you decide to try

If you do decide to try couples therapy, the single most important thing you can do is have a real say in the choice of therapist. In my experience, reluctant partners who are handed a fait accompli often disengage, while reluctant partners who participate in choosing the person they are going to work with often do well.

  1. Pick the therapist yourself or at least be one of two voices in the choice. There is a practical guide on how to choose a couples therapist in London that goes into credentials, modality, fit, location, cost and the questions worth asking.

  2. Use the free consultation properly. It is a chance to assess the therapist as much as it is the other way around. If anything feels off, you have lost nothing by saying so. I’ve created a guide to help you prepare for the consultation.

  3. Pay attention to whether the therapist asks questions of both of you equally, or whether they lean toward your partner. The early signs are usually visible within the first session.

  4. Ask how they will track whether it is working. The trial above suggests that this matters.

  5. Trust your own read. If the therapist feels off after a session or two, say so out loud. A good therapist will take the feedback seriously. A bad one will explain it away. The response itself tells you something.

  6. If it would help to know what happens in a first session before deciding, there is a piece on what happens in your first couples therapy session, and one on what to expect from relationship therapy.

What if you decide it is not for you

Some reluctant partners read all of this and still decide couples therapy is not for them. That is a legitimate position, and it is worth saying so directly. A piece written for the reluctant reader cannot be a piece that only validates one outcome.

A few things to know if that is where you land. These come from my clinical experience.

  • Your partner may pursue individual relational therapy on their own. This is not usually a tactic against you. It is real work that helps them think about their part in the relationship. Some reluctant partners find, six months on, that their partner has changed in ways that make the original conversation about therapy easier to have again. Some find the opposite, and the relationship reaches its own conclusion. Either outcome is information.

  • 'Not now' is different from 'never'. A reluctance that softens over time is, in my experience, much more common than a reluctance that stays fixed. If you decide it is not for you right now, it does not have to be a permanent position.

  • A 'no' that is genuinely understood and respected by your partner is different from a 'no' that becomes another argument. The first can be lived with. The second tends to get worse and is often the situation that brings couples to therapy a year or two later anyway, at which point the work is harder than it would have been earlier. If conversations about this keep turning into arguments, how to stop arguing with your partner may help, and so may when to go to couples therapy if you are unsure about timing.

If you are wondering whether therapy of any kind is for you, Is therapy right for me? and 8 reasons people think therapy isn't for me may help.

A note on the research

Most of the studies I have cited were of married or mixed sex couples, or did not specify, so I would be careful about assuming their figures describe your relationship exactly. If you are in a same sex relationship or a consensually non monogamous one, finding a therapist who understands your context matters, and I write about gay couples therapy and lesbian couples therapy.

A final thought

There is something inherently odd about a therapist writing a long piece about whether you should consider therapy, and the irony of that is not lost on me. The honest position is that I cannot tell you whether to do this. What I can do is try to make the decision a more informed one than most people make.

In my experience, most reluctant partners were not as resistant as they thought they were when they first walked in. They were sceptical, which is different. Scepticism is curiosity with its arms crossed. It can become real engagement once the room feels different from what they expected.

If you would like to find out without committing to anything, the free 30-minute consultation is in person or online. It is a conversation, not a session. You can book it on your own to assess the therapist before deciding whether to involve your partner. If after 30 minutes you decide this is not for you, you have lost nothing.

About the author

Mark Ryan is a BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist working with individuals and couples across three central London locations: Kensington, Pimlico, and Angel. His practice focuses on relationships, intimacy, and sexuality, with particular experience supporting LGBTQ+ couples and clients navigating non-traditional relationship structures.

If you would like to talk about whether couples or individual relational therapy might be a fit, you can book a free thirty-minute consultation, available in person or online.

References

Anker, M. G., Duncan, B. L., & Sparks, J. A. (2009). Using client feedback to improve couple therapy outcomes: A randomized clinical trial in a naturalistic setting. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 77(4), 693 to 704.

Anker, M. G., Owen, J., Duncan, B. L., & Sparks, J. A. (2010). The alliance in couple therapy: Partner influence, early change, and alliance patterns in a naturalistic sample. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 78(5), 635 to 645.

Christensen, A., Atkins, D. C., Baucom, B., & Yi, J. (2010). Marital status and satisfaction five years following a randomized clinical trial comparing traditional versus integrative behavioral couple therapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 78(2), 225 to 235.

Doss, B. D., Atkins, D. C., & Christensen, A. (2003). Who's dragging their feet? Husbands and wives seeking marital therapy. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 29(2), 165 to 177.

Doss, B. D., Rhoades, G. K., Stanley, S. M., & Markman, H. J. (2009). Marital therapy, retreats, and books: The who, what, when, and why of relationship help seeking. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 35(1), 18 to 29.

Friedlander, M. L., Escudero, V., Heatherington, L., & Diamond, G. M. (2011). Alliance in couple and family therapy. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 25 to 33.

Hewison, D., Casey, P., & Mwamba, N. (2016). The effectiveness of couple therapy: Clinical outcomes in a naturalistic United Kingdom setting. Psychotherapy, 53(4), 377 to 387.

Lebow, J. L., Chambers, A. L., Christensen, A., & Johnson, S. M. (2012). Research on the treatment of couple distress. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 38(1), 145 to 168.

Schechinger, H. A., Sakaluk, J. K., & Moors, A. C. (2018). Harmful and helpful therapy practices with consensually non monogamous clients: Toward an inclusive framework. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 86(11), 879 to 891.

Previous
Previous

Why Couples Argue More on Holiday (and What to Do About It)

Next
Next

What to Do When Your Partner Won't Go to Couples Therapy