Dating in the New Year? Start With What You Want From a Relationship

By Mark Ryan, BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist, individual therapy in London

The new year has a way of making people think about their love lives. After the family gatherings, the couples at every table and the quiet of early January, many single people find themselves wondering whether this is the year to start dating, or to date differently. If that is you, you may already have a list in your head. Kind, funny, ambitious, good with family, attractive, not like the last one.

In my work with people who are thinking about dating, the first thing I notice is usually that the list is about the partner. People often think carefully about what they want in a partner before they have thought about what they want in a relationship. I think it needs to be the other way round. Before you can recognise a good match, you need to know why you want a relationship at all, and what you most want to get from the relational space.

This article looks at why that order matters, what the research says about partner lists, and two questions worth asking of anyone you date. It also looks at how your own patterns shape who you choose, and how to date without repeating an old story. It is written for single people of any gender and orientation, whether you have been single for a long time or only recently.

Article Summary

  • Being single is not a problem to be fixed. Dating can come from wanting something and not only from feeling you should.

  • Start with why you want a relationship and what you want from it, before you think about the kind of partner you want.

  • Research suggests that lists of traits predict attraction less well than most people expect, and that fear of being single can lead people to accept less than they want.

  • Ask two questions of anyone you date. Is this person someone who is up to building the relationship I want with me, and am I attracted to, interested in and admiring of them?

  • Your own patterns, including your attachment style, travel with you into dating, so it helps to know them before you start.

Being Single Is Not a Problem to Be Fixed

Before anything else, a word about the starting point. New Year messages can make single people feel that they are behind, or that the year is a chance to finally put things right. That framing does not help. People who are single are a varied group, and many are content and some are not.

A review of research on singlehood looked at what is linked to wellbeing within the single population, not at singles compared with couples. It found that wellbeing varied with several things, including how secure a person felt in their attachments, how much they feared being single and how much support they had from friends and community. Attachment security was linked to higher wellbeing, and attachment anxiety and a high fear of being single were linked to lower wellbeing. The authors also warned against narratives that treat singlehood as a deficit (Girme and colleagues, 2023). That is a review of existing studies, so it describes patterns across many groups and not what is true for you.

What it suggests is that how you feel about being single, and how secure you feel in yourself, may matter as much as whether you are dating. If you have recently come out of a relationship, there may be grieving or adjusting to do first, and life after separation looks at starting again. If this is your first Christmas on your own, your first Christmas after separating may help.

Start With Why You Want a Relationship

The flip I suggest is simple to say and harder to do. Instead of asking what you want in a partner, ask why you want a relationship, and what you want to get from the relational space.

Here are some questions to sit with, ideally in writing.

  • Why do I want a relationship now? What am I hoping it will give me?

  • What are the two or three things I most want from it? For some people it is companionship, for others it is feeling deeply known, building a home or a family, shared adventure, physical closeness or being able to rest in someone's care.

  • What do I want it to feel like on an ordinary Tuesday, and not only on a good weekend?

  • What kind of partner am I when I am at my best, and when I am under stress?

  • What would I want to be different from past relationships, and what do I want to keep?

These questions matter because the reason you want a relationship shapes what you accept. One of the clearest findings here concerns fear. In a series of studies, people who feared being single were more likely to stay in less satisfying relationships and less likely to end them. They also showed more romantic interest in dating targets who were less responsive and less attractive, and they were less selective in a speed dating event. Fear of being single was unrelated to their stated standards for a partner, apart from higher standards for parenting, so the fear did not show up in what people said they wanted (Spielmann and colleagues, 2013). Someone can have a perfectly good list and still settle, if fear is steering. I would treat the findings as a useful warning and not a verdict on anyone.

If you notice fear in your answers, that is not a failing. It is useful information, and it is a good reason to slow down, to take care of how you are feeling and perhaps to talk it through with someone before you start.

If You Are Not Sure You Want One Yet

Answering the why questions sometimes shows that the honest answer is not yet. You may want closeness but not the work of dating, or you may notice that the wish comes mainly from other people's expectations, such as family at Christmas, friends who are pairing off or a sense that time is passing. That is worth knowing. A relationship started mainly to ease pressure can be hard to sustain, because it rests on what you want to escape and not on what you want to move towards.

It can help to separate three things that often get mixed together. There is the wish for connection, which can be met in many ways, including friendship and community. There is the wish for a particular kind of relationship, such as a long term partner or a family. And there is the pressure to have one by a certain time. Each may need a different response.

Not being sure is a legitimate place to start. You might use the new year to find out more about what you want, to build the parts of your life that you would want to keep in a relationship, and to try dating lightly without a fixed expectation. The aim is to be honest with yourself and, when the time comes, with the people you date.

If you would like something to work through at home, on your own and at your own pace, our Resources page brings together a mix of free and paid resources for individuals and couples. You will find free guides such as jealousy and insecurity, and needs and boundaries reflection, alongside paid workbooks on themes such as attachment, and desire and intimacy. Each one is gently paced and written for ordinary evenings.

Why a List of Traits Often Does Not Help

Lists feel safe because they seem to give you control. The research suggests they are less reliable than we hope. A review and meta analysis of what people say they want in a partner found that physical attractiveness predicted how people evaluated romantic targets quite strongly, for men and for women, and that earning prospects predicted it only weakly. It also concluded that ideals work better in some situations than others, and it highlighted a difference between how people respond to hypothetical partners and how they respond in live interactions (Eastwick and colleagues, 2014).

A later study put this to a sharper test. Romantically unattached people completed more than a hundred measures of their traits and preferences, and then met every other participant at a speed dating event for four minutes each. Statistical models could predict some of how much each person tended to like others, and how much they were liked, but they could not predict who liked whom in particular, using what people had reported before the dates. The authors concluded that the compatibility part of mating is hard to predict before two people meet (Joel and colleagues, 2017). Those participants were meeting people of the opposite sex, so it tells us nothing about other kinds of pairing.

A recent review suggests why. Matching what you say you want with what a person has often turns out to be surprisingly weak, and the same trait can mean different things depending on who has it. The authors suggest that compatibility may come less from matching preferences with traits than from how two people repeatedly extend and build on shared positive experiences over time (Eastwick and colleagues, 2026). It fits what I see. Compatibility looks less like a match found and more like something built.

In one study of 1,014 Chinese singles, people preferred an ideal partner who was similar to them in personality, physical attractiveness and social resources (Liu and Zhang, 2023). Similarity is a reasonable thing to want, though it is one preference among many. It also helps to know that your own preferences are not fixed. A study that followed 204 adults for 13 years found that ideals for a partner were moderately stable, and that some changed with life stage. Interest in status and resources, for example, rose with age and parenthood. People had only partial insight into how their ideals had changed (Driebe and colleagues, 2024). The sample was mostly well educated and from a Western background, so it is a guide and not a rule. It does suggest that a list you wrote years ago may no longer describe you.

A picture of a couple in a close embrace at nighttime while fireworks explode in the sky

Being single is not a problem to be fixed. Dating can come from wanting something and not only from feeling you should.

Two Questions to Ask of Anyone You Date

If lists are not enough, what can you use? I suggest two high level questions, and you need both.

First, is this person someone who is up to building the relationship I want with me? This is the question about the relationship, and it comes from knowing why you want one. It asks whether this person wants something similar, whether they can offer it and whether the two of you can build it together. It is less about who they are on paper and more about how they are with you. Are they reliable and responsive? Are they interested in knowing you? How do they handle disagreement, and a difficult feeling? Can the two of you talk about what each of you wants?

Second, is this someone I am attracted to, interested in and admire? This is the question about the person. Attraction and interest matter, and so does admiration, which is easy to overlook. Admiring someone means respecting how they live and how they treat people, and it can help keep warmth alive when the early excitement settles.

A good relationship needs both. A person can be wonderful and not be up to the relationship you want, and a person can be exactly what you want in a relationship and leave you cold. Putting both questions together is how you work out whether your wants and your approach will fit with theirs.

There is some support for looking at what happens inside the relationship. A large project analysed 43 studies that followed couples over time, and looked at which self reports best predicted relationship quality. The strongest relationship specific predictors were perceived commitment from the partner, appreciation, sexual satisfaction, the partner's perceived satisfaction and conflict. Individual differences such as life satisfaction, negative affect, depression and attachment anxiety and avoidance also mattered. People's own reports of their relationship predicted much more than traits did, and the partner's reports added little beyond them (Joel and colleagues, 2020). Those were people already in relationships, and the data were self reports, so it cannot tell you how a new date will turn out. It does suggest that what matters shows up in how it feels to be in the relationship, such as whether you feel valued, whether they seem committed and whether conflict is workable.

In practice, after a few dates, it can help to ask yourself some quiet questions. How do I feel about myself when I am with them? Do I feel more like myself or less? Can I say what I want? Are they curious about what matters to me? These are small signs of whether the relationship you want is possible with this person.

Knowing Your Own Patterns

You are the one constant in your dating life, so it is worth knowing how you tend to behave in relationships. That includes your attachment style, which is the way you tend to seek and manage closeness. People with an anxious style may worry about being left, read signals too quickly and push for reassurance. People with an avoidant style may value independence, feel crowded by closeness and withdraw when things deepen.

These patterns often show up later than the early dates. In a study of 1,345 young adults in dating relationships, anxious attachment became a stronger predictor of lower satisfaction and commitment in longer relationships than in shorter ones (Freeman and colleagues, 2023). The study was a snapshot and not a follow up of the same people, and it involved young adults, so it is a hint and not a rule. It fits with how many people describe their experience. The first weeks feel easy, and the old pattern appears once it begins to matter.

Knowing this in advance lets you notice the pattern early, and choose differently. The articles on anxious attachment and avoidant attachment look at each in depth, and can you change your attachment style asks whether they have to stay fixed. If you keep finding yourself in the same kind of relationship, why do I keep ending up in the same relationship looks at why. If jealousy and insecurity tend to appear for you, our free guide on jealousy and insecurity is a gentle place to start.

How to Date Without Repeating the Old Story

Once you know why you want a relationship, what you want from it and how you tend to behave, you can date with more intention. Some things that help.

  • Write down your why and your two or three priorities. Keep them somewhere you can look at them after a date, particularly when you feel swept along.

  • Notice what you overlook. If you find yourself explaining away something that matters to you, such as unreliability or a lack of interest in you, that is worth pausing on.

  • Share what you are looking for, early and lightly. You do not need a speech. Saying what you want from a relationship tells you a lot about how the other person responds.

  • Let it build. If compatibility is something two people build, it makes sense to give things a little time and to notice whether the building is shared.

  • Check in with yourself after a date. Ask how you felt, not only whether you liked them. Calm and interested is a very different signal from anxious and hooked.

  • Keep your friends and your life. A relationship is more likely to be a choice when it is not your only source of connection.

  • Be kind when it is not right. Ending things clearly and respectfully is part of dating well, and part of knowing what you want.

  • Do not settle out of fear. If you notice a wish to hold on to someone mainly because being single feels frightening, give yourself time and some support.

If you tend to fall quickly, or to lose yourself in the early stages, the article on the anxious avoidant trap may help you see how that dynamic forms.

Making a New Year Intention That Fits

If you would like to set an intention for the year, make it about something you move towards and not something you avoid. "I want to date people who want to build something" is easier to act on than "I will not date another person like my ex". An intention might be to spend an evening writing down your why, to join something where you will meet people who share your interests or to talk to a therapist about your patterns before you begin. It does not need to be a plan for finding a partner. Choosing to get to know yourself better is also a way of setting yourself up for a good relationship. If a resolution is what you are after, the article on new year relationship resolutions looks at why small, specific changes tend to last better than big decisions.

Many people find it helps to explore this with support. Our paid attachment workbooks are written for individuals who want to understand their patterns at home, at their own pace.

How Therapy Can Help When You Are Single

Therapy for single people is not about fixing you before you are allowed to date. It is a chance to understand what you want from relationships, why you want it and how you tend to show up. In individual therapy we can look at your history in relationships, at the patterns you notice, at what fear or pressure may be doing to your choices, and at what a good relationship would look like for you.

Many people find that this makes dating feel clearer and less pressured. You may notice sooner what is right for you, and what is not. If you are curious about how it works, a single prepared session is one way to explore a particular question without committing to weekly sessions.

If you would like support with thinking about dating and relationships in the new year, I offer a free 30 minute consultation, in person in London or online. It is a chance to talk about what you want and to see whether working together would help. You can book through the link below.

About the Author

Mark Ryan is a BACP Accredited Psychotherapist and NCPS Accredited Relationship Therapist based in London. He works with couples and individuals on communication, conflict and the patterns that shape relationships over time. Read more about individual therapy in London.

References

Driebe, J. C., Stern, J., Penke, L., & Gerlach, T. M. (2024). Stability and change of individual differences in ideal partner preferences over 13 years. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 50(8), 1263 to 1279. <https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11193321/>

Eastwick, P. W., Luchies, L. B., Finkel, E. J., & Hunt, L. L. (2014). The predictive validity of ideal partner preferences. A review and meta analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 140(3), 623 to 665. <https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23586697/>

Eastwick, P. W., Zhao, A. A. Z., & Zietsch, B. P. (2026). Mate preferences and the compatibility puzzle. Trends in Cognitive Sciences. <https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42957551/>

Freeman, H., Simons, J., & Benson, N. F. (2023). Romantic duration, relationship quality, and attachment insecurity among dating couples. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 20(1), 856. <https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9820285/>

Girme, Y. U., Park, Y., & MacDonald, G. (2023). Coping or thriving? Reviewing intrapersonal, interpersonal, and societal factors associated with well being in singlehood from a within group perspective. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 18(5), 1097 to 1120. <https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10475216/>

Joel, S., Eastwick, P. W., & Finkel, E. J. (2017). Is romantic desire predictable? Machine learning applied to initial romantic attraction. Psychological Science, 28(10), 1478 to 1489. <https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28853645/>

Joel, S., Eastwick, P. W., Allison, C. J., Arriaga, X. B., Baker, Z. G., Bar-Kalifa, E., et al. (2020). Machine learning uncovers the most robust self-report predictors of relationship quality across 43 longitudinal couples studies. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(32), 19061 to 19071. <https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7431040/>

Liu, J., & Zhang, Y. (2023). Singles' similarity preferences in an ideal partner. What, when, and why. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1088591. <https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10019068/>

Spielmann, S. S., MacDonald, G., Maxwell, J. A., Joel, S., Peragine, D., Muise, A., & Impett, E. A. (2013). Settling for less out of fear of being single. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 105(6), 1049 to 1073. <https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24128187/>

Next
Next

New Year, Same Argument: What Your Fight Is Really About